Somewhere along the way I became the type of person who makes things more difficult than they need to be. Ask me to empty the vacuum cleaner and five minutes later the entire thing will be disassembled on the living room floor and I’ll be in the kitchen soaking all the removable parts in a bowl of suds and scrubbing the folds of the filter with a Q-tip. Shortcuts never seemed to interest me. So when I was asked, in my senior year of high school, to read the Gettysburg Address at the city’s Memorial Day parade, I took this to mean: Memorize it and give it all you’ve got.
May 23, 1989
1. Wind Beneath My Wings, Bette Midler
2. Through the Storm, Aretha Franklin and Elton John
3. This Time I Know It’s For Real, Donna Summer
4. Soldier of Love, Donny Osmond
5. After All, Peter Cetera and Cher
6. I Only Wanna Be with You, Samantha Fox
7. Iko Iko, The Belle Stars
8. We Can Last Forever, Chicago
9. Like a Prayer, Madonna
10. Giving Up on Love, Rick Astley
Niagara Falls had three high schools, and the city would rotate asking each for its valedictorian to read an historic speech at the annual parade, and, as luck would have it, the stars aligned for me. The vice-principal stopped me in the hallway one day and handed me a typed copy of the Gettysburg Address, asking if I’d be interested. It never occurred to me to say no, which proves that I wasn’t nearly as smart as people thought I was. The real clue, for anyone who’d been paying attention, came two years earlier when I’d foolishly agreed to dress up in a rabbit costume and hand out candy to the participants of the science fair held in the gym for the local grammar schools. To be punched in the nose on a normal day is, I imagine, bad enough, but to be punched in the nose while wearing an oversized rabbit head by a sixth grader whose lopsided volcano entry merely gurgled and coughed but by no means erupted escalates you to a level of stupid reserved for a select few.
Niagara Falls had three high schools, and the city would rotate asking each for its valedictorian to read an historic speech at the annual parade, and, as luck would have it, the stars aligned for me. The vice-principal stopped me in the hallway one day and handed me a typed copy of the Gettysburg Address, asking if I’d be interested. It never occurred to me to say no, which proves that I wasn’t nearly as smart as people thought I was. The real clue, for anyone who’d been paying attention, came two years earlier when I’d foolishly agreed to dress up in a rabbit costume and hand out candy to the participants of the science fair held in the gym for the local grammar schools. To be punched in the nose on a normal day is, I imagine, bad enough, but to be punched in the nose while wearing an oversized rabbit head by a sixth grader whose lopsided volcano entry merely gurgled and coughed but by no means erupted escalates you to a level of stupid reserved for a select few.
I was required to wear a tie to school Monday through Friday, so wearing one on a Sunday afternoon was not my idea of a good time. It was warm that day, and I sat beside the mayor in the back seat of a white Cadillac convertible as it crawled along the parade route, up Main Street to a triangular patch of grassy land opposite the post office. The mayor and I took our seats on a portable stage along with a rabbi, other city officials, and a tiny woman who was introduced as the city’s oldest-living World War I widow. She got applause for standing up.
Among the gathered crowd were my mother, my grandmother, and my Great Aunt Angie, a woman convinced that anyone holding a plate covered in Reynolds Wrap is either going to or coming from a party. “Look at that,” she’ll say, spotting some random people with aluminum foil. “I’ll bet they had a party,” and she’ll nod and smile in approval because Aunt Angie approves of all parties. Blinking lights. Toothpicks. Saran Wrap. These things all signal potential fun, for which she is always on the lookout. So in preparation for my reading of the Gettysburg Address, Aunt Angie, wearing a polyester pant suit, spread a blanket in the shade of a tree and used her patent-leather purse to anchor down a large, helium-filled balloon with the California Raisins on it.
When the moment arrived I stepped to the podium and silently congratulated myself for having had the foresight to memorize the speech, because no one affiliated with the event had bothered to supply me with a copy of it. Why I hadn’t thought to bring my own copy is further proof of my stupidity, but that was that and there I was, on my own, just me and my memory and a park full of people. And so I began: “Four score and seven years ago, our fathers brought forth on this continent a new nation, conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal.” One of the organizers stepped up behind me and whispered for me to move closer to the microphone. I wanted to turn to him and say And then what? Because I had no idea what came next. My mind had gone blank, replaced by a white hot burning sensation that had shot its way from my stomach straight up into my head. I stood there and stared at my hand for an inappropriate amount of time, hoping for the words, even just one of them to get me started again, and when none came I seriously considered making my next ones: Sorry, that’s all I’ve got and then walking away.
What could they do? They couldn’t force me to say what I couldn’t remember. Oh sure, I might be reviled for a while, written up in the Gazette as the rain on the parade, the low point of the day, the guy who made a mockery of Abraham Lincoln right there in front of the oldest-living war widow, but I was willing to accept all that if I meant I could go sit down again.
But then the words returned. Slowly at first. And to hide my panic that’s exactly how I said them. Slowly. As if the pauses were intentional. As if I were making it all up on the spot, writing it myself. I calmly crossed one foot over the other and took hold of the podium, as if to say I’m settling in here, folks, and you should too because this could take a while. I gave it all I had, turning each word, each phrase, carefully out of my mouth and looking out at the crowd as if asking everyone to really listen to what I was saying. And, clearly listening, everyone looked back at me as if asking themselves Where the hell did they get this kid?
Years later when I was asked to do a reading at my grandmother’s funeral, the cheerful woman planning the mass gave me a copy of a passage from the Book of Deuteronomy. I read it over once or twice and then, having learned my lesson and taking no chances that I’d find a bible in the church, folded it and slipped it into one of my pockets. By the time the priest called me up to the podium, I’d forgotten which pocket. With a suit on there were at least six possibilities. As I stood there at the microphone patting myself down like a criminal, searching for the feel of crinkling paper, I felt the uncomfortable silence in the church growing longer and saw a bunch of swollen, soupy eyes staring at me, imploring me to get the show on the road. So I began from memory. “Four score and seven years ago...”
Years later when I was asked to do a reading at my grandmother’s funeral, the cheerful woman planning the mass gave me a copy of a passage from the Book of Deuteronomy. I read it over once or twice and then, having learned my lesson and taking no chances that I’d find a bible in the church, folded it and slipped it into one of my pockets. By the time the priest called me up to the podium, I’d forgotten which pocket. With a suit on there were at least six possibilities. As I stood there at the microphone patting myself down like a criminal, searching for the feel of crinkling paper, I felt the uncomfortable silence in the church growing longer and saw a bunch of swollen, soupy eyes staring at me, imploring me to get the show on the road. So I began from memory. “Four score and seven years ago...”

